Smoked Pork Tenderloin as an Open Faced Sandwich

This recipe outlines a basic Smoked Pork Tenderloin sliced thin as an open faced sandwich, which I personally love. Alternatively, you can serve the pork tenderloin in thick slices with mashed potatoes and veg, or in a 4-6 oz piece, more similar to a steak.
The best part about this recipe, is it allows you, the cook, to adjust the seasoning to your liking. A basic Smoked Pork Tenderloin recipe allows you the flexibility on flavor but provides the foundations to what makes a pork tenderloin recipe delicious:
- Do NOT overcook the pork. This keeps the meat moist. Most individuals don’t purposefully request dry mealy meat at a restaurant, and if you use an instant read thermometer, you will cook to the doneness you prefer!
- Seasoning heavily (so its well seasoned and tastes good!) You can start with my Kitchen Pantry Spice Rub and add or tweak according to what you prefer.
- Slicing against the grain so that the pork is tender when you bite into it
- For sandwiches, I slice the pork tenderloins (across the grain) thin

Smoked Pork Tenderloin as an Open Faced Sandwich
5 from 1 vote
One of my favorite quick and casual meals is to serve Smoked Pork Tenderloin as an Open Faced Sandwich. Perfect with aioli, barbecue sauce, mustard and pickles, pork tenderloin has a lighter appeal for lunch or dinner. Yum!
Servings: 4 people
Ingredients
- 1 pork tenderloin makes 4-5 sandwiches when sliced 1/8”/3 mm thin
- All purpose spice rub look for the recipe for SmellaQue Kitchen Pantry Rub (in the photos, Head Country Championship Seasoning – Original, Kosmos Honey Chipotle Killer Bee and Simply Marvelous Sweet Seduction)
- Condiments: aioli BBQ sauce, mustard
- Sandwich additions: Pickle slices arugula, spinach, thin apple slice
Method
- Set up your grill to cook indirect (push charcoal to one side and cook meat on the other side) or use an offset smoker for indirect cooking so the indirect side is 300F.
- While the grill and smoker are warming up, place pork tenderloins onto baking sheet. Remove the membrane by placing a thin sharp knife under the membrane and cut parallel to the tenderloin.
- Generously sprinkle spice rub(s) onto the pork tenderloin. Ideally you can barely see the meat through. Flip the pork tenderloin over and generously sprinkle the other side of the tenderloin so that it is seasoned on all side.
- Place pork tenderloin on indirect side of grill or offset smoker for 20 on indirect grill or 30 minutes on offset smoker. This cooked the tenderloins to 110F. The bark should begin to set (the spice rub is adhering to the meat so that it doesn’t rub off when you rub your finger against the surface). You can also rotate the tenderloins or move around on the grill if your coals are getting hot and burning the rub.
- Flip pork over on the grill or offset smoker.
- Using an instant read thermometer, at the doneness of your choice by probing in the middle of the length of the tenderloin, remove the pork tenderloin off the grill or smoker and place onto a baking sheet or pan, loosely cover the pork loin with aluminum foil and allow to rest. This can vary between 20 -60 minutes.
- US Department of Agriculture recommends cooking to 145F with at least a 3 minute rest. https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2022/10/03/cooking-meat-it-done-yet#:~:text=Cook%20raw%20beef%2C%20pork%2C%20lamb,minutes%20before%20cutting%20or%20consuming 145F -150F medium rare150F-155F medium155F-160F medium-well160F well
- Rest pork tenderloin under a loose piece of tin foil for at least 15 minutes or until ready to serve.
- For sandwiches: With a sharp knife, slice pork tenderloin 1/8”/ 3 mm thin to make a pile of pork tenderloin on a burger bun or slice or bread. Top with barbecue sauce and enjoy!
- Personal Note: On an offset smoker, at 300F, I cooked the pork tenderloins on a Yoder Wichita offset smoker, top shelf by the exhaust for 30 minutes, flipped the tenderloins and cooked an additional 50 minutes to 135F.
Author: janice_smellaque
euyr9c